“What, me worry?” – distorting climate change data


Peter Gleick has a simple useful article in Forbes illustrating various ways that climate change deniers/contrariness cherry pick data to support claims that global warming is not occurring (see “Global Warming Has Stopped”? How to Fool People Using “Cherry-Picked” Climate Data). He is referring to an increasingly common argument that deniers/contrarians are promoting in OpEd columns and opinion pieces in newspapers. We have seen it here too, and the comments at New Zealand’s premium climate change denier blog Climate Conversation Group are full of such claims.

Recently I dealt with that argument as expressed by an old colleague of mine in a letter to the NZ Listener (see Open letter across the barricade). In the “open letter’ I reconstructed my own example of how global temperature data can be cherry picked to promote the “global warming has stopped” myth. But I had in the back of my mid  an animated graph which showed this more clearly.  Now I have found it – and reproduce it below. It’s from Skeptical Science (a mine of information) and is usually referred to as The Escalator.

I think this demonstrates the dishonesty of cherry-picking beautifully.
Mind you, it doesn’t stop motivated deniers and bloggers picking up these dishonest articles and promoting them to similarly motivated reader. Have a look at Local Whale Oil’s No Need to Panic About Global Warming.”
A classic example of the activity that goes on in the climate change denier echo chamber.

5 responses to ““What, me worry?” – distorting climate change data

  1. In what way John?

    I am drawing attention to a common misrepresentation and example of cherry picking by climate change deniers/contrarians. The article you linked to just appears to be an attempt to get together links from Wikipedia etc. without any point I can see (perhaps you can?).


  2. I would like to add to the discussion but I am very lazy.
    So here is a link.
    Ah, well…um…the thing is I don’t really have a link.
    However, I have taken intellectual laziness to the next level.
    Some people discuss a topic. Some people just dump a link and run off without so much as an iota of personal input. Yet I have decided to escalate the laziness and not even bother to provide a link in the first place.
    I like to think that one day, people will just leave blank spaces in the comments section by way of their contribution. It’s the next logical step.


  3. Richard Christie

    Some people just dump a link and run off without so much as an iota of personal input.

    He’s probably off spamming Hot Topic with Andy Scrase, who is currently active over there.


  4. This is huge.
    I hope this gets all the loving attention it deserves.
    Detail by detail.
    Name by name.
    Dollar sign by dollar sign.

    Heartland Institute Exposed: Internal Documents Unmask Heart of Climate Denial Machine


Leave a Reply: please be polite to other commenters & no ad hominems.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s