Ukraine – a beginner’s guide

The Author of this Dorset Eye article, Ukraine – a beginner’s guide, says:

“In 2014, the journalist and writer John Pilger wrote an article for The Guardian newspaper entitled ‘In Ukraine the US is dragging us towards war with Russia’.[i] Eight years later, in 2022, this prediction came true when Russia invaded Ukraine. Readers should be aware that I am anti-war, and therefore not in favour of any country invading any other. This article is to help readers understand why Russia invaded Ukraine.

A peaceful outcome is possible if negotiators from the US, Ukraine, Europe (particularly Germany and France) and Russia are able to sit down and agree a solution. Negotiations have to deal with two sets of connected problems. The first is about how different regions in Ukraine are governed. The second is about the role that Ukraine plays internationally.  “

I have watched Ukraine closely since 2013/2014 (the democratically elected government was overthrown in a coup in February 2014) and think the author is completely correct. One cannot understand the current war unless one understands the problems Ukraine has with ethnic differences and what this means for local government and language/cultural rights. We also need to acknowledge the rise of extreme and often violent ultranationalism and the way Ukraine has been used in the geopolitical struggle between the USA and the Russian Federation.

I think the article is a little bit simplistic – but certainly not as simplistic and biased as the information our mainstream media subjects us to.

There is just so much ignorance about this war, the reason for it and the lead up to it. We are bombarded with so much biased and fake news and disinformation. But this article provides a good introduction (and it is well referenced) for anyone wishing to understand what is really going on.

 

5 responses to “Ukraine – a beginner’s guide

  1. Thanks for your email. I have sent an email to UN Dispatch very recently regarding peace in Russia and Ukraine. Here’s what I wrote.

    Dear Sir, I suggest you meet Putin, Zelensky and other leaders to discuss how sincere and honest Guterres is for bringing peace to Russia and Ukraine. As I studied his visit to Russia and Ukraine I felt him not sincere enough to develop peace between the two. I am an ordinary citizen of Myanmar, one of the least developed countries, my sources of information is very poor. With your capacity and knowledge, you discuss the topic with relevant leaders, you may find out what is best for the world and UN. ASAP.

    With unconditional and unlimited Love “METTA” Aung Min Organizer for Engineering World’s Peace Tel(+95)0943202550

    On Tue, 26 Apr 2022, 02:53 Mark Leon Goldberg / UN Dispatch, wrote:

    I tried to forward this to you but failed so I copied. Hope you find it interesting and able to do more. With unconditional and unlimited Love “METTA”

    Like

  2. David Fierstien

    Yeah. This guy seems like a completely unbiased source of information with no axes to grind: “It is important to understand the broader context of the world we live in. The US government is the biggest criminal organization in the world, having committed the worst crimes of the 21st century . . ”

    Maybe you could provide some pages from Putin’s personal diary for a little less bias than what this guy is spewing. “THE Worst Crimes Of The 21st Century.” I don’t think it would be difficult to cite a few crimes that have occurred since the beginning of the 21st Century worse than anything the U.S. has done recently. Two examples come to mind immediately.

    Like

  3. David Fierstien

    You say you believe “this author is completely correct.” This passage jumped out at me: “The US has biological weapons labs in Ukraine, many close to the Russian border.” Wow! That’s quite a claim. According to Politifact, it’s a lie. https://www.politifact.com/article/2022/mar/11/russia-china-and-tucker-carlson-lack-evidence-ukra/ . . . And according to Politifact, it’s a lie. https://www.politifact.com/article/2022/mar/17/how-broken-urls-helped-fuel-unfounded-conspiracy-t/ There is ZERO evidence to support that claim.

    Perhaps some critical thinking skills should have been employed before reading the article. Right, Ken?

    Like

  4. David – you claim I believe ““this author is completely correct” and say critical thinking skills mat be required. But in doing this you ignore completely what I actually wrote:

    I “think the author is completely correct. One cannot understand the current war unless one understands the problems Ukraine has with ethnic differences and what this means for local government and language/cultural rights. We also need to acknowledge the rise of extreme and often violent ultranationalism and the way Ukraine has been used in the geopolitical struggle between the USA and the Russian Federation.”

    So, you then go on to completely ignore or cover up the specifics. My reference to the ethnic problems in Ukraine, the importance this has for regional government and language/cultural rights, the role of ultranationalists/neo-Nazis and the way Ukraine has been used in the geopolitical struggle between the USA and the Russian Federation.
    It seems that you are the one needing critical thinking skills if you can ignore completely what I said and attempt a diversion.

    The question of the US military funding of biological research labs in Ukraine is a separate issue. An interesting one – I have a number of the contracts and research documents from those labs and their significance should be discussed. I understand the documents have been forwarded to the UN.

    However, these are complex and are not an issue here.

    But it is uninteresting you don’t want to discuss the real issues discussed here and which have led up to the current war.

    Like

  5. David, I can understand why you refuse to face up to the crimes of the US. But has Russia done anything a serious as the theft of 350 billion dollars of another country’s reserves, or funding and arming neo-Nazis responsible for the atrocities committed in Mariupol?

    But enough of this aboutism. Why not discuss what is happening in Ukraine at the moment. The problems of ultranationalism and neo-Nazis. The constitutional problems., The refusal to carry out commitments under the Minsk agreements. And the way the US has use Ukraine to avoid assisting in development of a viable security architecture for Europe.

    Like

Leave a Reply: please be polite to other commenters & no ad hominems.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s