Society’s ” Christian values”

In New Zealand we often hear the claim that the ethics, morals and values of our society are Christian. Some will even go as far as proposing that this claim should be enshrined in legislation. That the government should declare the country Christian in law. This proposal is rejected by members of other religions, the non-religious and many Christians. Many people are unhappy with the proposal because they see it as a step towards a theocracy.

Human values, not Christian values

In fact, the values of our society are not specifically Christian. The values are common to other religious and non-religious beliefs. However, the popular labeling of these beliefs is hard to counter. Even the non-religious will use terms such as “Christian charity” or “Christian kindness.” Perhaps there are equivalent terms in other societies – “Buddhist charity,” “Muslim Charity,” and “Hindu Charity” all meaning the same thing – charity. Perhaps this is just the chauvinism of the major religion. But it is demeaning for those who don’t belong to that religion. And sometimes these claims of Christian values are presented in a hostile manner. For example, when some Christians make the claim that the non-Christians have “stolen their values”, or only have these values because they have been raised on a Christian society, etc.

Ideological chauvinism

A similar example of ideological chauvinism occurred under the “developed socialism” of the last years of Breshnev’s rule in the USSR. Soviet ideologists of the time proudly proclaimed a new “Soviet man” displaying communist ethics and morality. Of course this was just an example of common human values, ethics and morality being claimed for a specific ideology.

To some extent this problem arises because of the popular conception that religions play a special, exclusive, role in moral guidance. Historically, religions did evolve as institutions codifying and teaching moral and ethical values. They also served the same purpose with legal and other social concepts, including justification for the existence and policies of the ruling caste. Religions also made claims to special knowledge about the natural world, about origins of the universe, life and humanity.

In modern society religion has largely conceded most of these roles. It is no longer seen by most people as a reliable source of information about the natural world or the origins of the universe, life and humanity. In this respect their ancient teachings are seen as myths. Similarly most countries now reject a special role for religion in their legal arrangements. Isn’t it about time Christianity also conceded that it has no special, exclusive, role in ethics and morality. That other ideological systems (non-religious and non-theist as well as theist) also codify and teach these common human moral and ethical values.

Dangers of “Christian values” claims

The danger of these sort of Christian claims is that they use common values to then attempt to impose a sectarian agenda on society. Claims of a “Christian society” and “Christian nation” are then used to impose irrational beliefs (e.g., creationism/intelligent design), sectarian expectations about human behaviour and the accompanying atmosphere of guilt (attitudes towards sex, dress, marriage). They are also used to justify imposing sectarian Christian ceremonies on society (national anthems, bans on trading on public holidays, imposition of Christian prayers).

Of particular concern is that “Christian values” are sometimes used to attempt to create hostility towards those with different beliefs, particularly those with atheist beliefs. By claiming exclusive right to these human values some Christians attempt to paint atheists as immoral, having not ethical or moral code. In effect they attempt to deny atheists rights to social participation – the right to be heard when society discusses ethical and moral questions.

Related Articles:
Religious Diversity Statement
Religious diversity includes “non-believers”
Destiny of Christian privilege?
Common values, common action?
Special rights for religion?
Humility of science and the arrogance of religion
Limits of science, limits of religion
Family planning and the inhumanity of religion
Theology of the Emperor’s New Clothes
Is religion the source of morality?
Religion and violence
Morals, values and the limits of science

5 responses to “Society’s ” Christian values”

  1. Ken,

    There really is so much we agree on… but alas…

    -d-

    Like

  2. Alas indeed – whatever that means.
    But I agree, when values and ethics are presented specifically people will mostly find agreement – despite the labels that give to themselves. The point is to stop those labels getting in the way of united action on the points of agreement.

    Like

  3. Agreed (a.k.a. ‘Amen’) to specific presentation clearing up fog, and united action across any and all label-lines…

    🙂

    -d-

    Like

  4. But reality reminds us that people do have an interesting tendency to network with (and create ‘labeled’ groups of) people who think like themselves. (and of course the labels are sometimes strictly guarded, and sometimes not)

    This grouping and networking (even labeling) isn’t itself the problem, it’s assuming you have the correct interpretation of the universe, and that you don’t need anyone else except you and your group – now THAT is a problem… …and I suspect a problem that both Christians and atheists make…

    …but of course, not really cool Christians and atheists like you and I (respectively) !!! 🙂

    -d-

    Like

  5. DONALD MONROE

    christians,values, strong powerful words. I FIND IT HARD TO BELEIVE THAT A GOOD CHRISTIAN, ALLOW OUR POLITIONS, TO STEEL FROM THE POOR AND GIVE TO THE RICH. OUR POLITIONS HAVE BECOME ECONOMIC TERRORIST TO AMERICA. A LOT OF THEM CLAIM TO BE CHRISTIANS, WHEN THEY ARE TOOLS OF THE DEVEL. LOOK WHAT POLITIONS HAVE DONE TO GODS CHILDREN , GODS CHILDREN. WHY IS IT SO HARD FOR THEM TO SERVE FOR THE GREATER GOOD. POLITIONS ARE BOUGHT AND PAID FOR BY THE DEVEL, THEY SEND OUR YOUNG TO WAR FOR RESOURSES, FOR THE BIG INTEREST. CHRISTIANS SHOULD BE MORE AWARE OF THE DEVELS TOOLS. ECONMIC TERRORISM IS HERE THE NEW THREAT TO EVERYTHING WE ARE, CHRISTIANS. THEY WANT YOUR MONEY AND YOUR RELIGION. WAKE UP POLOITIONS SHOULD BE WATCHED.

    Like

Leave a Reply: please be polite to other commenters & no ad hominems.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s